Equine disputes are disputes or misunderstandings or misinterpretations that occur commonly in equine businesses or the equine industry. These disputes can be about different aspects of horse ownership, training, competition, business transactions, and more and often require equine professionals such as equine solicitors to resolve these disputes. Here are some common examples:
Horse ownership disputes: Disagreements over horse ownership can arise when there are conflicting claims or disputes regarding the transfer of ownership.
Co ownership arrangements, or issues arising from sales or leases of horses.
Breach of contract: Disputes may occur when one party fails to fulfill the terms and conditions outlined in a contract related to horses. This could involve disagreements over breeding contracts, sales contracts, training agreements, boarding contracts, or partnership agreements.
Training and care disputes: Conflicts can arise between horse owners and trainers or boarding facilities regarding training methods, the quality of care given to the horse, feeding and medication protocols, exercise routines, or overall management of the horse.
Competition related issues: Disputes can emerge in equestrian competitions such as disagreements over judging decisions allegations of rule violations challenges regarding prize money distribution
Resolution of Equine Disputes
Equine disputes occur oftenly in the equine world and so their resolution requires professional guidance such as of an equine solicitor.
Equine dispute resolution methods, such as arbitration, mediation, and litigation, can be employed for different circumstances and it depends on the nature of the dispute, which method you are using and also according to the choice of the parties having dispute. Here’s brief discussion about each of the method used in resolution of equine disputes:
Arbitration is a method in which a neutral third party called an arbitrator is given a charge to hear the dispute and decide according to the conditions. The decision of the arbitrator is often considered as enforceable just like a court judgment. It is a good option especially when both the parties desire for a resolution that is private, efficient, and final.
It is commonly used in contract disputes such as misinterpretations,misunderstandings, disagreements or breach of the contract by parties over horse business which includes sale or purchase of horse and issues related to equine insurance.
Mediation is the method which involves the use of a neutral third party which is known as a mediator to help and facilitate communication and negotiation between the parties among which the dispute is present. This mediator party does not give a verdict but instead of this, it helps both of the parties to reach an agreement which is acceptable for both of the parties.
Mediation can be helpful when the parties in a dispute want to maintain or repair a relationship and do not want to end it as mediation ensures open dialogue and mutually discussed problem-solving techniques. It is often employed to solve the conflicts over horse training, racing ,boarding arrangements, equine insurances and also in resolution of disputes that are between equestrian professionals and clients. This method is more suitable because it involves mutual coordination between both parties and it typically resolves the dispute in most of the cases.
Litigation is a method of resolving equine disputes which involves the court system. It includes presenting the case before a judge or jury, who study the case , listen to the arguments of equine solicitors from both sides and decide on legal grounds making equine law as the basis of their final verdict on the matter. Litigation is mostly employed when other resolution methods have failed, or when the complexity of legal issues is of greater extent that require a court’s interpretation.
It is a formal process and it often results in wastage of time as these cases sometimes run for a long time. Equine litigation may be vital in cases involving negligence, breach of contract, equine insurance issues or issues of animal welfare.This method is employed as the last option in the process of resolution of equine disputes because most of these disputes get resolved either by mediation or arbitration.
Equine disputes are a major issue for the equine industry and often require professional help for their resolution . When choosing the appropriate method for the resolution of the equine dispute, it is advisable to keep the factors such as the urgency of the matter in mind and the desired level of privacy for both parties must be provided and the dispute must be resolved according to complexity of the matter. The availability of resources while resolving an equine dispute must be kept in mind. In some scenarios, alternative dispute resolution methods, such as arbitration or mediation, can be more handy and can resolve the dispute in much less time as compared to traditional litigation systems involving proper jury and court sessions .
However, it is advisable to consult a legal professional such as equine solicitor who is familiar with equine law to study and estimate the complexity of the dispute and provide suitable guidance about how it should be resolved based on your specific circumstances.