● Live from USEF Medal Finals
Audio only radio commentary from Ellie Ferrigno and Piper Klemm.

Press play to listen in!

Biggest Underdog Wins in Kentucky Derby History

The Kentucky Derby may be known as “the most exciting two minutes in sports,” but for some underdog horses, it has been a stage to shock the world and etch their names into the history books. Over the years, long-shot winners with jaw-dropping odds have defied expectations, rewriting narratives of underachievement into legendary tales that stand the test of time. And the good news is, this year’s installment of the storied Churchill Downs showdown is just around the corner. 

The 2025 Derby takes place on May 3rd, but even though the clash is still weeks away, sports betting sites already have their prices listed as to who they think the major players are. One popular online sports betting site currently has Journalism listed as the shortpriced +400 frontrunner for glory. With the betting picture constantly changing as race day approaches, following the latest Kentucky Derby odds, contenders, and expert analysis can help fans stay ahead of the action through the BetUS Kentucky Derby hub. The thoroughbred was recently crowned the top three-year-old in the world with an impressive victory at Santa Anita Park, and the colt will be looking to rubber-stamp his status in Kentucky next month. 

At the opposite end of the spectrum, the likes of Captain Cook, Getaway Car, and John Hancock are the rank outsiders, with some outlets pricing them as long as +5000 to emerge victorious. With weeks to go until race day, those odds could drift even further, but as these tales will tell you, anything can happen at the Greatest Show on Turf. 

Donerail

Odds: 91-1 | The Longest Odds to Ever Win the Derby

The story of Donerail stands as the benchmark for underdog victories in Kentucky Derby history. With staggering odds of 91-1, he remains the longest shot ever to take the title. The thoroughbred’s path to victory in 1913 was paved with skepticism. Owned and trained by Thomas P. Hayes, Donerail hadn’t been given much attention by bettors or bookmakers. Even Hayes seemed to approach the race with tempered expectations, asking jockey Roscoe Goose only to aim for a solid finish.

On the day of the race, Donerail’s trip to Churchill Downs was symbolic of his uphill battle. The horse had to walk miles through dirt and cobblestones just to reach the track because there wasn’t enough space to stabilize him on-site. Yet, when the gates opened, he pushed past two far more fancied opponents in Ten Point and Yankee Notion, to claim a shocking win. 

Rich Strike

Odds: 80-1 | A Victory Born of Chance

Rich Strike’s victory in 2022 is a modern-day fairy tale. The horse wasn’t even supposed to race in the Derby, with trainer Eric Reed receiving a phone call just 48 hours before the showdown to see if his prized charge would be interested in entering the field as an alternate after Ethereal Road was scratched. The answer to that, of course, was yes, and the rest, as they say, is history. 

The 90-1 outsider arrived at Churchill Downs almost anonymously, with little fanfare or expectation. And nobody expected what was about to happen. 

As the crowded field came down the stretch, Rich Strike was performing admirably, sitting back in sixth place after a decent showing. Jockey Sonny Leon asked for more from the horse in a bid to push him into the places, but what he got in reply was an absolute rocket ship. Rich Strike not only kicked on, but he also powered forward almost like a car being kicked into turbo. 

He charged past the heavily favored Epicenter and Zandon to secure a scarcely believable first-place finish, delivering an 80-1 upset and sending onlookers into an absolute frenzy. 

Country House

Odds: 65-1 | The First Disqualification Victory

If there was ever a Derby win that defined the phrase “expect the unexpected,” it’s Country House’s controversial victory in 2019. At 65-1 odds, few saw this horse as a serious contender. On race day, however, what unfolded was nothing short of historic. 

Country House initially appeared to finish second behind Maximum Security, the heavy favorite. But as the horses circled back to the paddock, an objection was raised.

Maximum Security had been accused of veering into another horse’s path during the final stretch, creating interference. After a stunning 22-minute deliberation by race officials, the frontrunner was disqualified, and Country House was declared the winner. It was the first time in the race’s 145-year history that a horse who didn’t cross the line first was awarded the roses, and while some viewed the victory as tainted, others celebrated it as a reminder that anything can happen under the Twin Spires.

Mine That Bird

Odds: 50-1 | Last to First in a Dazzling Stretch Run

Mine That Bird’s win in 2009 is a story of pure grit. Coming into the race, he was dismissed as a nobody. Even during the race, he was an afterthought, trailing the pack by a wide margin halfway through. NBC announcer Tom Durkin noted his position, describing him as “well behind the rest of them,” not even within reach of the leaders.

But what happened next was nothing short of extraordinary. Hugging the rail with surgical precision, jockey Calvin Borel urged Mine That Bird forward along the inside. The horse sliced through the field like a bolt of lightning, stunning favorites such as Pioneer of the Nile and Dunkirk. Mine That Bird didn’t just win—he claimed the largest margin of victory the Derby had seen in over six decades. That rail-hugging ride remains one of the most memorable moments in Kentucky Derby history.

Giacomo

Odds: 50-1 | A Photo Finish for the Record Books

Giacomo’s path to glory was as unassuming as his place in the betting order. The colt, owned by music mogul Jerry Moss, had only one previous victory to his name before arriving at Churchill Downs. That win came at a maiden race, making his entry less than inspiring to even his most loyal supporters.

During the 2005 race, Giacomo’s odds of 50-1 reflected his status as a mere participant rather than a contender. But as the race unfolded, he proved critics wrong. He patiently hovered near the back of the pack, waiting for his moment. 

When the front-runners began to tire after a blistering start, Giacomo surged forward. The finish was so close it required a three-way photo to confirm his victory. 

Continue Reading

April 19, 2024

Advertisement