Brought to you by The Plaidcast
Hunters were designed to mimic the challenges of the hunt field, testing style, brilliance, and natural ability. But according to Geoff Case, USEF R Judge, trainer, and clinician, today’s hunter ring has strayed far from those origins.
“Every time you change something and it makes something more difficult, it makes it harder for the horses to go around like that,” he said. “I feel like the hunters were creating dressage with jumps in the way. Essentially it’s the same eight-jump pattern everywhere you go.”
The result? A discipline that increasingly looks like performance art, polished, robotic, and predictable, rather than a sport designed to test horse and rider.
Penalizing Personality
Case believes hunters have become overly rigid in penalizing anything that deviates from a narrow picture of perfection. Cross-cantering, missed lead changes, even headshaking are all faults that weigh heavily on a score. “It was supposed to mimic the hunt field,” he noted. “And now it’s something else entirely.”
That rigidity discourages brilliance. Horses are worked until they are flat and expressionless, their personality stripped away to avoid deductions. “To be crisp and jump their best, they need to be a bit fresh,” Case explained. “But we’ve worked the brilliance out of them. You take the personality out.”
When a Chip Ends the Day
The mindset around mistakes is also harsher in hunters than in other disciplines. Piper Klemm observed that hunter riders can be “debilitated by their 76,” while jumpers with a rail down might be frustrated but move on. Case agreed, adding: “You pop chip in the hunter ring and it’s like your life is over. You want to crawl in a hole. You pop chip in the jumper ring and, if the horse leaves it up, you laugh about it and show the video to your friends.”
That difference in culture drives a wedge between hunters and other disciplines. For perfectionists drawn to the hunter ring, small imperfections feel catastrophic, while jumper riders are often able to shrug off a mistake.
Performance Art or Sport?
In Case’s words, hunters today have become “performance art more than a sport.” The pursuit of an idealized picture, a horse going perfectly quiet, in perfect rhythm, without the slightest bobble, has overtaken the original goal of showcasing athleticism in a natural way.
Even efforts to inject brilliance have fallen flat. When international hunter derbies were introduced, horses were supposed to be allowed to be expressive and a little fresh. But in practice, the judging didn’t change. “They were supposed to be allowed to play a little bit,” Case said. “But the way those things were judged changed very little, and that was still penalized. So people went back to the same old way.”
A Different Approach to Judging
Case believes judges need to start peeling back the curtain for exhibitors, explaining why a round scored an 85 instead of a 90, or a 75 instead of an 80. Without that transparency, frustration builds and riders walk away. “It’s easy for people to go in the jumper ring. You knocked it down or you didn’t, you were fastest or you weren’t,” he said. “In hunters, there’s this nebulous understanding of how they’re judged.”
Making the criteria more open, and rethinking what is and isn’t penalized, could help bring artistry back into the ring, without punishing horses for showing brilliance.
What’s at Stake
The danger of staying on the current track is that professional hunter divisions will continue to shrink until they disappear altogether. If hunters are reduced to a discipline of routine, robotic rounds at the lower levels, the system that built America’s strongest riders will collapse.
Hunters don’t need to be perfect. They need to be alive, reflecting the challenge, athleticism, and joy that first defined the division. Case summed it up bluntly: “If that’s what people want, we can keep doing it. But they have to understand the repercussions at the higher level are just gonna be those professional divisions dwindling and dwindling until they’re dead.”
To hear the complete discussion with Geoff Case listen to The Plaidchat, and to get from today’s top equestrians, subscribe to The Plaidcast on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite platform.
