Brought to you by The Plaidcast
Winter has a way of sneaking up on a rider’s confidence. The daylight shrinks, the indoor suddenly feels so much smaller and horses get fresh. Goals that felt easy in July suddenly feel out of reach. It’s a season that can make even the most dedicated riders question where their progress has gone.
Mental skills coach Tonya Johnston believes winter isn’t a setback at all. In fact, she says winter can be one of the most productive periods of a rider’s year if they understand how to work with the season rather than fighting against it.
Recognize the Season You’re In
The first step, Tonya explains, is accepting that winter riding is fundamentally different from riding in the summer. “You have to acknowledge the season you’re in,” she says. “The expectations you had in July don’t apply in November.”
Cold temperatures tighten muscles. Indoor rings restrict pace and lines. Weather disrupts schedules. Horses may get less turnout and more enthusiasm. None of these factors reflect your ability or your horse’s willingness. They’re simply the conditions winter brings.
Tonya stresses that riders often lose confidence not because they’re performing poorly, but because they’re comparing winter rides to their best days outdoors. That comparison isn’t just unhelpful, it’s distorting.
“You’re usually doing better than you think you are,” she says. Winter magnifies riders’ negativity bias, making small imperfections feel like big problems.
Adjust Your Goals to Match Reality
Once riders accept winter for what it is, they can begin to shift their goals in a way that keeps confidence steady. “That same number of jumps, the same amount of space, the same intensity—it’s not going to happen right now,” Tonya says. “So don’t hold yourself to expectations that belong to another season.”
She encourages riders to set winter-appropriate goals like strengthening flatwork, improving transitions, refining rideability, or practicing straightness in smaller spaces. These goals still matter. They’re still meaningful. They just don’t rely on summer conditions.
Tonya also reminds riders that winter goals should feel achievable inside their current circumstances, not outside them. “It’s about meeting yourself where you are and where your horse is,” she says.
Remember Your Why
One of Tonya’s most grounding pieces of advice is to reconnect with your reasons for riding is remembering your “why.” “When things get tough or you’re frustrated, remembering your why helps anchor you,” she says.
Maybe your why is the horse you love. Maybe it’s the feeling of progress. Maybe it’s quiet time in the barn. Winter strips away distractions and forces riders to look inward at what matters. Returning to that core purpose helps keep frustration from eroding confidence.
Your why is the compass that keeps you oriented when everything else feels unpredictable.
Let the Small Wins Count
Winter is not a season of dramatic leaps forward, but it is a season rich with small moments of improvement, and Tonya wants riders to notice them. “Maybe your horse felt tight, and you rode through it. Maybe the ring was crowded, and you stayed focused. Maybe your warm-up felt good. Those things matter.”
She says riders tend to skip right past what went well and go straight to critique, especially in winter. That habit quietly chips away at confidence.
Tonya argues that collecting and celebrating small wins is one of the most important ways to stay motivated and mentally strong. Those moments build a foundation that summer riding will draw from later. “You’re usually further along than you think,” she emphasizes. The small things really are progress.
Plan for Winter’s Physical Challenges
Winter doesn’t just change the mental landscape. It changes the physical one too. Tonya points out that winter riding affects a rider’s body in very tangible ways.
“The cold affects your breathing, your muscles, your focus,” she explains. “It influences how you ride.”
She also notes that horses may feel fresher or tighter with less turnout. Indoor rings can add distractions or increased traffic. Riders often underestimate how much these shifts impact rhythm, confidence, and mental energy.
Tonya isn’t telling riders to push harder, but encouraging them to plan smarter. Adjust expectations for warm-up energy. Allow more time for muscles to feel loose. Understand that your ride may unfold differently indoors. Confidence grows when riders anticipate winter’s realities instead of ignoring them.
You Don’t Need Perfect Rides to Build Confidence
One of Tonya’s most encouraging takeaways is the reminder that confidence isn’t tied to perfect rides, but to consistency. “You don’t need perfect rides to build confidence,” she says. “You just need to show up for yourself and keep moving forward.”
Tonya stresses that confidence is built from the cumulative effect of many small, steady efforts—not single breakthroughs. A short ride, a focused walk session, a productive warm-up… all of these accumulate. Winter riding may not always feel amazing, but it’s still productive. The progress might be quieter, but it’s still progress.
A Season Designed for Quiet Progress
Winter is not a pause in a rider’s development. It’s a recalibration. It’s a time for strengthening fundamentals, refining feel, and learning how to stay mentally steady even when conditions aren’t ideal.
Tonya encourages riders to “bookend the year” to see winter not as a setback, but as an early chapter in the story of next year’s success. What feels incremental now becomes the foundation you’ll stand on when show season arrives. “Show up for yourself,” she says. “Stay engaged. You’re doing better than you think.”
Winter becomes a season of quiet confidence. Not because everything feels perfect, but because you learn how to ride through moments that aren’t.
Hear more from Tonya Johnston on Plaidcast Episode 458 for additional insight into riding, mindset, and performance.
