Brought to you by The Plaidcast
When nerves show up, most riders instinctively try to make them go away. They take a breath, tell themselves to calm down, or start questioning why they don’t feel more confident. The assumption is simple: if the nerves disappear, the ride will improve.
But in her conversation on episode 462 of The Plaidcast, mental skills coach Tonya Johnston explains why that approach often has the opposite effect. Trying to fix nerves in the moment doesn’t usually make riders more effective. Instead, it pulls their attention away from what actually supports good riding.
The problem isn’t the nerves themselves. It’s where the rider’s focus goes once those nerves appear.
When Attention Shifts Away From the Ride
Tonya explains that riders run into trouble when they start evaluating how they feel instead of staying connected to what they’re doing. The moment riders begin asking questions like Why am I nervous? or How do I calm myself down?, their attention turns inward.
That inward focus competes with the information riders need most in the saddle—feel, timing, balance, rhythm, and awareness of the horse. Instead of processing what’s happening underneath them, riders begin monitoring themselves.
As Tonya explains, neutral thinking is designed to interrupt that pattern. “It’s very behavior-focused,” she says, emphasizing that effective riding comes from action, not emotional analysis.
Once attention leaves the task, decision-making suffers—not because the rider feels nervous, but because they’re no longer fully present.
Why Emotion Management Adds Pressure
Many riders believe that calming down is a prerequisite for riding well. Tonya challenges that belief directly. Emotions, she explains, don’t need to be improved or controlled before a rider can take useful action.
Trying to manage nerves adds an extra layer of effort at the worst possible moment. Instead of having one job—ride the horse—the rider now has two: ride and fix how they feel.
That second job often increases tension. Riders become more self-conscious, more analytical, and less responsive. Instead of simplifying the moment, emotion management complicates it. Riding does not require emotional control. It requires functional focus.
Neutral Thinking Changes the Question
Rather than trying to change emotion, Tonya introduces neutral thinking as an alternative approach. Neutral thinking shifts attention away from feeling and toward behavior.
The central question becomes: “What do I do now?”
Tonya returns to this question repeatedly in the conversation. It doesn’t ask riders to feel better or think differently. It asks them to identify the next useful action—something concrete and actionable in the present moment. That question keeps the rider oriented forward. Instead of spiraling into self-evaluation, the rider stays engaged with the ride.
Nerves Don’t Mean Something Is Wrong
Another important distinction Tonya makes is that nerves themselves are not a problem. Nervousness often shows up because something matters. It doesn’t mean a rider is unprepared or incapable.
Neutral thinking allows riders to acknowledge nerves without letting them dictate decisions. Nerves can exist in the background while the rider stays focused on the task. Riders can feel nervous and still ride effectively because the feeling itself does not prevent good decisions—distraction does.
Using Neutral Thinking Under Pressure
Pressure moments are when riders are most tempted to fix how they feel. Warm-ups feel messy. Courses change. The environment feels heavier than expected. These are precisely the moments where neutral thinking becomes most valuable. Instead of asking What’s wrong with me?, riders return to “What do I do now?”
That shift keeps attention anchored in the present. It prevents riders from replaying mistakes or predicting outcomes. It allows them to respond to what’s actually happening. By focusing on behavior instead of emotion, riders create clarity where there would otherwise be noise.
Letting the Ride Regulate Emotion
One of Tonya’s most practical insights is that effective riding often regulates emotion on its own. When riders are actively engaged—making decisions, supporting the horse, staying organized—the mind has less room to spiral. Calm doesn’t need to be forced. It often appears as a byproduct of staying connected to the task.
Neutral thinking removes the pressure to feel a certain way before performing. Riders don’t have to wait until nerves disappear to ride well.
Tonya’s message is not that riders should ignore emotions. It’s that emotions don’t need to lead.
Trying to fix nerves often keeps riders stuck in self-monitoring. Allowing nerves to exist while redirecting attention forward keeps riders moving.
Good riding doesn’t begin when nerves disappear. It begins when riders stop asking how they feel—and return to the simple, functional question that keeps them present: What do I do now?
Want more insight from Tonya Johnston? Listen to her full conversation on The Plaidcast and subscribe to The Plaidcast for practical tools to support your mental game in the saddle.
