● Live from USEF Medal Finals
Audio only radio commentary from Ellie Ferrigno and Piper Klemm.

Press play to listen in!
Photo © Heather N. Photography

Stop Telling Yourself Stories About Your Horse

Brought to you by The Plaidcast

Humans are remarkably good at creating explanations for why horses behave the way they do, especially when the behavior is frustrating, inconvenient, or frightening. 

According to neuroscientist and horse trainer Janet Jones, the problem is that those explanations can quickly become assumptions about motivation. The scientific term is anthropomorphism: the tendency to assign human attributes to animals. With horses, Jones says that may mean attributing strategy to a horse that escapes its stall or malice to a horse that bucks a rider off. The behavior itself is real. The question is whether the human explanation for it is.

Behavior Is Not the Same as Motivation

“With horses, we see people sometimes ascribe strategy to a horse who escapes his stall,” Jones said. “Or they ascribe malice to a horse who bucks a rider off.”

That distinction is important because we often know what a horse did while knowing much less about why he did it. Horses do silly things sometimes. That’s very true, but deciding that the horse carefully planned the escape or acted out of malice adds a layer of interpretation that may or may not be accurate.

Jones warns that once we decide we understand the horse’s motivation, the next step is often blame. A horse bucks, the rider falls, and people quickly point toward the horse.

“Bad horse,” Jones said.

That label can influence what happens next. Jones says assigning blame in this way can lead to punishment and, in some cases, abuse. The rider may believe they are correcting intentional misconduct when they are actually responding to an explanation they have created themselves.

“A horse does what he does because of natural defense mechanisms, the way that his brain is hardwired, the rewards that he has received for doing things in the past, et cetera,” she said. That asks us to consider that what looks like spite, calculation, or deliberate defiance may have other causes rooted in the horse’s biology or previous experiences.

If we start with the conclusion that the horse is being malicious, we may stop asking useful questions. If instead we recognize that there could be another explanation, we leave room to observe more carefully and understand the behavior more accurately.

Anthropomorphism Isn’t Entirely Bad

Jones is careful not to argue that anthropomorphism is always harmful. In fact, she believes recognizing similarities between humans and animals has helped change the way people understand animal intelligence and emotion.

“The good side of anthropomorphism is that noting similarities between animals and humans has led us to realize that animals are much smarter and more emotional than we ever knew,” she said. Animals were held in far less esteem in the human world only a few decades ago, and recognizing their emotional and cognitive capacities has helped change that.

The problem comes when similarities become assumptions. Appreciating that horses are intelligent and emotional does not mean we should automatically assume their motives mirror our own.

Jones approaches anthropomorphism from the perspective of a scientist. Rather than automatically accepting or rejecting a human-like explanation for horse behavior, she suggests treating it as something that can be investigated.

“My own feeling is that we need to use anthropomorphism to test hypotheses,” she said.

If we suspect that a horse is developing a complex strategy, Jones argues that we should test that suspicion to determine whether it is actually true. At the same time, she does not think those possibilities should simply be dismissed without study. In her view, science has sometimes made that mistake in the opposite direction, rejecting ideas about animal cognition too quickly.

We can’t assume horses think exactly like humans, but we also can’t assume they’re not capable of sophisticated behavior. We need to separate what we suspect from what we actually know.

Ask What Else Could Explain It

Tonya Johnston connected Jones’ discussion to the stories riders can build around their horses. Once we settle on an explanation, we can begin acting as though that interpretation is fact, even when other possibilities exist.

Jones agreed that people often settle too quickly on the first available answer.

“Too often we just jump to the first conclusion,” she said, “or perhaps we jump to the first thing we have been told in the past without really thinking about, well, maybe there could be a different explanation for this.”

That may be one of the most useful questions a rider can ask: Could there be another explanation?

Maybe the behavior reflects a natural defense mechanism. Maybe something similar has been rewarded in the past. Maybe another factor is involved that we have not yet considered. The goal is not to replace one unproven story with another. It is to remain curious long enough to recognize that our first interpretation may not be the only one.

When something goes wrong with a horse, labels can provide a quick and satisfying explanation. The horse was stubborn. The horse was naughty. The horse knew exactly what he was doing. But those conclusions can stop the thought process at exactly the moment when more thought is needed.

Jones’ approach asks riders to separate behavior from assumed motivation. Observe what actually happened. Consider what you know about the horse’s biology, previous experiences, and learned behavior. Then examine the story you are telling yourself and ask whether there may be another explanation.

That does not mean horses are simple or unintelligent. Jones argues quite the opposite. It means respecting their intelligence enough to try to understand it on its own terms rather than automatically translating every behavior into a human motive.

To hear the full conversation with Janet Jones and Tonya Johnston, listen to episode 489 of The Plaidcast. Subscribe and follow The Plaidcast on your favorite podcast platform for more conversations from throughout our industry.

Continue Reading

November 3, 2026

Advertisement