Trusting the Ride: Winning Thoroughbred Hunter Horse of the Year with Gio Lemon  

Caden Nolt and Gio at 2025 Junior Hunter Finals. Photo © Winslow Photography

By CADEN NOLT

Winning Thoroughbred Hunter Horse of the Year is one of those moments that still feels a little unreal. As a 17-year-old rider, it is easy to believe that honors like this are meant for riders who are older, more experienced, and further along in their career. That has made this recognition even more meaningful to me. It was not just a ribbon or a title. It represented patience, belief, and a deep level of trust built over time between me and my horse, Gio. 

From the beginning Gio made it clear this season was going to be about trust and fun.  Nothing about our journey followed a straight line, and that is what made it so rewarding. A one-eyed Thoroughbred competing competitively in the hunter ring is not something you see every day, and Gio challenged expectations by showing up and doing his job with confidence.  

Along the way, some doubts came from outside the rings as well. At one point, I was told that Gio should not even be allowed to compete, that a one-eyed horse had no place in the hunter ring. Hearing that was difficult, especially as a young rider, but those words forced me to look closer at what truly matters. Gio has never been limited by having one eye. He schools, shows, and tries with the same heart, intelligence, and ability as any other horse. What some people saw as a reason to disqualify him became a reminder for me to trust my horse and to let our performance speak for itself. 

Gio does not need sympathy or lowered expectations. He simply needs the opportunity to do his job, and he has proven time and time again that he belongs. Every time he steps into the right, he does so with confidence and pride. I am grateful that I get to be the one in the saddle.  

Caden and Gio. Photo © Kelly Lapp

If there is one thing Thoroughbreds guarantee, it is that no two rides are ever the same. Gio kept me laughing just as often as he kept me on my toes. There were moments of brilliance and other rounds that made me think, how did we get here? The process was full of character, much like him. Celebrating the win felt even sweeter knowing how much joy, learning, and growth was wrapped up in the journey itself.  

The most valuable lesson of the season was learning to truly trust Gio. He does not need to be micromanaged. He needs confidence. He taught me to ride with intention and to think carefully about every decision I make in the saddle. When I stopped riding every stride and started believing in his instincts, everything changed. Our rounds became smoother, more relaxed, and more connected. He taught me that trust is a decision you make every time you pick up the reins.  

Thoroughbreds have my heart because they ask more of you as a rider. They are sensitive, intelligent, and honest. You can’t fake it with them. They know exactly what you are bringing to the saddle. That authenticity is why I stay committed to the breed. When a Thoroughbred like Gio gives you his best, it is earned, and that makes every success feel more meaningful. His success reinforces my belief that Thoroughbreds are capable of excelling at the higher levels when given the opportunity, patience, and respect they deserve. 

I have always loved a challenge, and Gio delivers one every ride. He pushes me to be better. More balanced, more thoughtful, and more present. Winning Thoroughbred Hunter Horse of the Year was not about perfection. It was about progress. It was about embracing the challenge instead of avoiding it and letting that challenge shape us into a stronger partnership.  

Caden and Gio competing at Swan Lake. Photo © Lia Sim Photography

This title represents trust, growth, and the undeniable magic of a Thoroughbred who believes in you as much as you believe in him. I would not have it any other way.  

None of this would have been possible without my trainer of the past four years, Madison Barnett. As a young rider, having someone who believes in you before the results show up makes all the difference. Madi has taught me far more than how to win. She has taught me how to ride with intention, patience, and genuine respect for the horses. She has guided me through the ups and downs of the season and pushed me to grow not just as a competitor but as a horseman. Her belief in Gio and me laid the foundation for everything this season became, and I am incredibly grateful for her support, knowledge, and unwavering dedication.  

With recognition comes responsibility. Winning Thoroughbred Hunter Horse of the Year allows me to advocate for responsible retraining programs, for thoughtful judging that rewards quality and correctness, and for owners and riders to consider Thoroughbreds not as exceptions, but as legitimate first-choice athletes. Each successful Thoroughbred in the hunter ring makes it easier for the next one to be taken seriously, and I am proud to be a part of it.