Brought to you by The Plaidcast
In the horse industry, it’s easy to blur the line between ambition and excellence. The stakes can feel high—financially, professionally, emotionally.
But according to performance coach and author Brad Stulberg, there is a hard boundary around true excellence, and it has nothing to do with ribbons.
“If you care deeply about cycling and you really want to win,” he says, “so you dope yourself to the gills with performance-enhancing drugs—but you value integrity—that’s not excellence.”
Excellence, as he defines it, is “involved engagement or caring deeply in something worthwhile that aligns with your values and goals.”
The Constraint That Protects You
Values are often treated as soft ideas—nice sentiments that live in a mission statement. But Stulberg frames them as something much more functional: constraints.
“In competitive pursuits,” he explains, “your values really act as an important constraint from you spiraling into obsession in some pretty dark places.”
Equestrian sport, like any high-level competitive arena, carries pressure. Pressure to move up quickly and produce results. Trainers must keep clients, sponsors, and owners satisfied. Without internal constraints, that pressure can distort decision-making.
The question becomes not “Is this excellent?” but “Will this win?” But those are not the same question.
Defining Excellence Beyond Outcome
Wanting to win is not the problem. “Do you want to win? Absolutely,” Stulberg says. “Is it okay to want to win and have intensity around that? Yes.”
But when winning overrides joy, integrity, or long-term development, something essential is lost. The misalignment might look like over-facing a young horse to chase points. Pushing through fatigue instead of prioritizing soundness. Compromising your own physical or mental health for one more class.
These choices feel justified and necessary in the moment. But examining your values may create pause.
Stulberg suggests identifying three to five core values that act as “guiding qualities” or “North Stars.” Examples include strength, kindness, discipline, respect, integrity, family, reputation, honesty.
And then comes the harder part: defining what those words actually mean in daily life.
“It’s not enough just to have five words that are inspirational,” he explains. “You have to know what they mean.”
In the barn, that might look like:
- What does integrity mean in how I prepare my horse?
- What does respect mean in how I talk to my team?
- What does discipline mean when I’m tired and tempted to cut corners?
- What does family mean when competition travel conflicts with home life?
When those values are clearly defined, they become a decision-making dashboard.
The Dashboard That Matters
Stulberg puts it plainly: “You want to know, are you living in alignment with your values?”
That alignment affects sleep, relationships, and identity. In a sport where careers can span decades and reputations matter deeply, alignment may be the most sustainable competitive advantage available.
The alternative is constant internal tension—winning externally while compromising internally, and that tension will catch up with you It shows up as burnout, resentment, and fractured partnerships. Most importantly, it shows up in horses that lose joy in their job.
True excellence, by contrast, builds something stable. It allows riders to pursue ambitious goals without losing themselves in the process.
Horse Welfare and the Long View
The horse industry depends on ethics. Success is achieved through partnership with an animal whose well-being depends on human decisions. Values are especially critical.
If a rider claims to value horse welfare, that value must show up in daily choices: rest days, veterinary care, training intensity, competition schedules. Alignment is not theoretical. It’s real and protects horse and rider from harm.
When your values act as constraints, they refine performance. They force creativity within ethical boundaries and encourage development over shortcuts.
“When you’re confronted with decisions,” Stulberg says, “you can ask yourself, what would a person of high integrity do? Or what would a person with deep respect for the craft do?”
The Long Game
Equestrian sport rewards patience. Horses develop slowly and partnerships deepen over time. Trust is built in layers. Values ensure that the path to the top of the mountain does not cost you the very qualities that made you want to climb it in the first place.
Want more insight from Brad Stulberg? Listen to episode 471 of The Plaidcast and subscribe on your favorite podcast platform for conversations with the most influential voices in the equestrian world.
