Brought to you by The Plaidcast
In many barns, calling a horse “a little footy” sounds almost casual. It’s a phrase often used to describe mild discomfort—something noticeable, but not yet alarming. But according to veteran farrier Todd Monahan, that kind of language can downplay what is often an early warning sign.
“When people say a horse is footy, what they’re really saying is that the horse is uncomfortable,” Monahan said. “They may not be lame, but something’s going on.” In his experience, that discomfort frequently reflects more than a localized hoof issue. Instead, it can be one of the first outward signs of metabolic stress.
Monahan has been shoeing horses for decades, including more than 20 years in Wellington, where he sees horses repeatedly under similar conditions. That consistency allows him to notice patterns that aren’t always obvious in a single exam. “These things don’t just happen overnight,” he said. “You don’t go from being fine to having a serious metabolic problem in one day.”
Early Signs Often Appear Before Diagnostics Change
One of the challenges with metabolic hoof issues is that they often surface before traditional diagnostics catch up. “A lot of times the bloodwork looks fine,” Monahan said. “But the horse is still telling you something through its feet.”
Those signals can be subtle. A slightly stronger digital pulse. Sensitivity on firm footing. A horse that feels cautious or reluctant, even though it’s still working and showing. Because these signs don’t always meet the threshold for lameness, they’re easy to dismiss.
But Monahan cautioned that feet respond quickly to changes in circulation and inflammation. “The foot is very sensitive to what’s happening in the system,” he said. When that sensitivity shows up, it’s often worth paying attention—even if everything else appears normal.
“Not Lame” Doesn’t Mean “Nothing’s Wrong”
One reason metabolic hoof issues can linger is that many horses remain functional. They continue to train, compete, and move forward in their programs. But as Monahan pointed out, continued performance doesn’t always mean the horse is comfortable.
“You can have a horse that’s still doing its job,” he said, “but that doesn’t mean everything’s right.”
Elizabeth Ehrlich, founder and president of Equine Elixirs, echoed that idea from a nutritional perspective. She emphasized that metabolic stress builds over time. “By the time you see a really obvious problem,” she said, “there’s usually been something going on underneath for a while.”
That lag between cause and visible consequence is what makes early hoof sensitivity so important. The feet can reflect metabolic strain long before it shows up as overt lameness or dramatic test results.
Seasonal Stress Reveals What’s Already There
Monahan also described how frequently these issues intensify with seasonal changes, particularly in hot, humid environments. “You see it more in the summer,” he said. “Horses that were just a little footy start to get more uncomfortable.”
Environmental factors like heat and moisture can amplify underlying metabolic issues, making them harder to ignore. But Monahan was careful to note that these conditions don’t usually create the problem—they reveal it. “The environment brings it out,” he said. “It doesn’t come from nowhere.”
Why Early Attention Matters
The longer these signs are dismissed, the fewer options remain. Once laminar stress progresses or structural changes begin, management becomes more complex. “When you catch it earlier, you’ve got more tools,” Monahan said. “When you wait, it gets harder.”
That’s where collaboration becomes essential. Both guests emphasized that hoof sensitivity isn’t something farriers, veterinarians, or nutritionists should address in isolation. “The feet are part of the whole horse,” Ehrlich said. “You can’t separate them from what’s happening metabolically.”
Listening Instead of Minimizing
Ultimately, Monahan believes the biggest risk lies in minimizing early feedback. Calling a horse footy can unintentionally frame discomfort as temporary or insignificant. But horses don’t offer feedback without reason.
“If a horse is telling you it’s uncomfortable,” Monahan said, “there’s a reason for it.”
Treating hoof sensitivity as information allows owners and professionals to intervene earlier, more thoughtfully, and with better outcomes. When those early signs are taken seriously, they become an opportunity to support the horse before a manageable issue becomes a long-term one.
Want more insight from Elizabeth Ehrlich and Todd Monahan? Listen to their full conversation on The Plaidcast for a deeper discussion on metabolic health, hoof-related issues, and long-term soundness in performance horses.
